Tuesday, October 16, 2012
Present: Abby Crocker, Kairn Kelley, Rodger Kessler, Ben Littenberg, Prema Menon, Connie van Eeghen
1. Start Up: Here’s to IT helpers who need screen shots of “Locked. You are not authorized to…” in order to believe that authorization is, in fact, denied.
2. Presentation: Rodger & Connie – Aim Statement and Approach sections of R03 grant application for Toolkit for Primary Care Behavioral Health
a. The group had an extensive and detailed discussion about how to present the design, which is essentially good, in ways that are easier to understand and better supported. Key ideas:
i. Eliminate redundancy and keep simplifying, starting with the Aims page.
ii. Conceptual diagrams should focus the reader on the key points for this, particular, application.
iii. Do not indulge in the luxury of stating in the narrative what is in a table, or vice versa. Choose one or the other; the page restrictions make this a necessity.
iv. Create new sections when logical: “Investigators” and “Intervention,” as examples.
v. Introduce the overall design in a few simple words.
vi. Keep Aim 1 and 2 design elements distinct from each other; they have different kinds of subjects, data collection methods, analyses, etc.
vii. Every figure or table should have a well-defined question that it is answering and it should answer it as clearly and simply as possible.
viii. Simplify the analysis to two observations and, in limitations, explain why this is not a limitation. Adjust for loss to follow up.
b. Thanks for everyone’s input. As usual, invaluable.
a. Oct 18: Christina Cruz, 3rd year FM resident with questionnaire for mild serotonin withdrawal syndrome
b. Oct 25: Abby: update (Connie by phone)
c. Nov 1: Kairn: final draft of article on IRR (no Connie)
d. Nov 8:
e. Nov 15:
f. Nov 22: THANKSGIVING… take the day off J
g. Nov 29: Prema: draft grant application
h. Future agenda to consider:
i. Kairn – review of draft article on IRR
ii. Ben: budgeting exercise for grant applications; NHANES – lower female mortality for women taking birth control medications
iii. Rodger: Mixed methods article; article on Behavior’s Influence on Medical Conditions (unpublished); drug company funding. Also: discuss design for PCBH clinical and cost research. Also: Prezi demo.
iv. Amanda: presentation and interpretation of data in articles
Posted by Connie at 10/16/2012 10:21:00 PM